Collin Creek Mall
Initial Impression: 3
- This mall is the oldest and most run down. It's obvious just driving up. Many store fronts are empty.
Shopability for Mom: 3
- The only stores that I would even consider shopping at are Dillard's and Macy's, and they're much less nice than the ones at other malls.
Shopability for Baby: 3
- There are the department stores and a gymboree, but not much else. Most of the stores in this mall seem targeted towards teens on a budget, all very off-brand.
Parking: 2
- The parking lots are very empty, so you're close to the door, but there isn't much shade, and no cover from the elements.
Walking Distance: 2
- There is a good bit of walking to be had at Collin Creek, as there are two stories in all of the four department stores, laid out on five spokes. It would be better if the old Mervyn's was not Amazing Jake's, which I don't think you're free to walk through.
Ease of Bail-out: 1
- The spoke design makes it easy for you to return to your car from any point in the mall, as long as you remember from which direction you came. You're never that far from where you started as the crow flies, which is nice.
Playground: 1
- This playground has cute animals and was not at all crowded on a weekday.
Snack Options: 3
- Most of the name-brand chains are no longer in the food court, so you either need to be adventurous or willing to stick to Sonic or Chick-fil-a.
People Watching: 2
- There are an interesting collection of people at this mall. There were a lot of intense mall walkers and a surprising amount of adult men, but not in a creepy way.
Air Conditioning in Main Hallway: 2
- It is muggy in this mall during the heat of Texas summer, which is disappointing since there aren't that many people in it, and it has the least amount of natural light.
Walkability: 2
- The mall was not crowded, but the department store floors are kind of junky which cuts down on the ease of walking.
Total (the lower, the better): 25
Willowbend Mall
Initial Impression: 1
- This mall is so pretty and fancy, and the store brands are top notch. I especially love the Neiman Marcus.
Shopability for Mom: 2
- For department stores, you have Dillard's and Macy's. I also shop at Ann Taylor Loft, H&M, J.Jill--their stretchy pants are the bomb diggity for a postpartum body--and Crabtree and Evelyn, where I never, ever buy anything, but I always, always use their La Source Hand Cream.
Shopability for Baby: 2
- The department stores are there, but the real baby gem is H&M. How is it that their stuff is so cute, fashionable, child-friendly, and affordable? I swear everywhere else carries the same Carter's stuff or clothes that are too expensive.
Parking: 1
- Empty parking garages, oh my! You don't have to worry for your lives getting to the door, and the car stays cool and out of the elements in a garage. Perfection!
Walking Distance: 3
- Willowbend only has three department stores, and those have three levels, unlike the mall. Because of this, I never remember to go up to the third floors, so the distance walked in the department stores is short. You would also have to walk outdoors to get to Crate and Barrel, so I avoid that.
Ease of Bail-out: 2
- It's a small mall, so even if you're clear at the opposite end of it from your car, you can power walk it in a few minutes.
Playground: 2
- The playground is heavily trafficked, and the medical theme could be a little scary. It's popular and directly next to Auntie Anne's, so it earns the second spot.
Snack Options: 1
- Om, nom, nom. You can get a cupcake from Sugar Queen, a hot cookie from Which Wich, ice cream from Haagen Daas, nuggets from Chick Fil A, tots from Sonic, a pretzel from Auntie Anne's, or free samples from any number of place. I especially enjoyed my bite of philly cheese steak from one of the booths the other day. Plus, the food court is pleasantly quiet, and you can watch kids body board while you eat.
People Watching: 3
- There aren't many people at Willow Bend, and they are all just so waspy and boring.
Air Conditioning in Main Hallway: 1
- Oh, glorious air conditioning! They're keeping the high end shoppers happy, and the crowds aren't overpowering the AC.
Walkability: 1
- This mall is not crowded, and the mall is well-appointed. You can easily power walk at a good clip without having to dodge people or objects.
Total (the lower, the better): 18
Initial Impression: 2
- This mall is the most popular mall, and for good reason. It's high ceilings and variety of well-maintained and stocked stores are appealing to the masses.
Shopability for Mom: 1
- I will shop at Dillard's, Macy's, Nordstrom for shoes only, Dick's Sporting Goods, Ann Taylor Loft, the Gap, Soma, Fossil, and Barnes and Noble.
Shopability for Baby: 1
- They even have a Pottery Barn for kids and Hanna Anderson. Must I elaborate?
Parking: 3
- Holy crowding, mama! It is hard to park here, especially in the one teeny, tiny, covered parking area.
Walking Distance: 1
- At six department stores, this one is a no brainer.
Ease of Bail-out: 3
- It's just one long mall, which makes bailing out a real challenge.
Playground: 3
- It made such an impression that I had to Google whether or not it had one at all. Thus, it earns last place. It might be lovely, but I have no way of knowing.
Snack Options: 2
- The food court has tons of options, and you can totally get Sugar Queen Cupcakes, but it loses points for how massive, hot, and unpleasant the seating in the food court is.
People Watching: 1
- Mall walkers! Mahjongg players! Kids of all shapes and sizes! It's a suburban playground!
Air Conditioning in Main Hallway: 3
- The high ceiling, burning natural light, and crowds make the whole thing pretty unpleasant in the summer.
Walkability: 3
- It's really quite crowded, which slows you down. The department stores are nice to walk through.
Total (the lower, the better): 23
The winner, for me, is Willowbend Mall, but I challenge you do your own scientific study and decide for yourself!



